GS 2 · 2021International Relations10 Marks

Q11.“The USA is facing an existential threat in the form of China, that is much more challenging than the erstwhile Soviet Union.” Explain.

Directive: Explain10 marks

Introduction

The assertion that China presents a more formidable existential threat to the USA than the Soviet Union holds merit, reflecting a shift from a bipolar ideological-military rivalry to a complex, multi-dimensional challenge.

Body

Nature of Soviet Threat

The Soviet threat was primarily ideological (communism vs. capitalism) and military (nuclear arms race, proxy wars), characterized by limited economic integration.

China's Multi-dimensional and Pervasive Threat

China's challenge is comprehensive and deeply integrated across various domains:

  • Economic: Deep interdependence, global supply chain dominance, currency influence.
  • Technological: Leadership in AI, 5G, quantum computing.
  • Military/Geopolitical: Rapid modernization (cyber, space, naval), expansion (BRI, South China Sea).
  • Ideological: Offers an alternative 'authoritarian state capitalism' model, challenging liberal democracy.

Unlike the Soviet Union, China's deep global economic integration makes 'decoupling' difficult. Its comprehensive power and long-term strategic vision pose a truly existential and pervasive threat to US primacy.

Conclusion

Thus, China's integrated economic power, technological prowess, and alternative governance model represent a more intricate and enduring challenge to US global leadership.

161 words · target ~150