Ethics · 2021Ethics10 MarksSection A

Q17.Impact of digital technology as reliable source of input for rational decision making is debatable issue. Critically evaluate with suitable example.

Directive: Critically evaluate10 marks

Introduction

Digital technology's role as a reliable input for rational decision-making is a complex and highly debated issue, offering both significant advantages and inherent challenges.

Body

Arguments for Reliability (Pros)
  • Enhanced data collection and faster processing.
  • Predictive analytics for forward-looking insights.
  • Potential for objective insights, reducing human error and bias.
Arguments against Reliability (Cons)
  • Data quality issues (garbage in, garbage out).
  • Algorithmic bias and privacy concerns.
  • Risk of over-reliance, diminishing critical thinking.
  • Ethical dilemmas and digital divide.

Consider AI in welfare distribution. While it can streamline processes and identify beneficiaries efficiently, biased training data might exclude deserving individuals, raising ethical dilemmas and questioning the rationality of outcomes. Its reliability is contingent on robust data governance and continuous auditing.

Conclusion

Ultimately, achieving truly rational and ethical decisions requires a human-in-the-loop approach, strong ethical AI frameworks, and vigilant oversight to balance potential with pitfalls.

139 words · target ~150