GS 2 · 2020Indian Polity15 Marks

Q7.Rajyasabha has been transformed from a ‘useless Stepney tire’ to the most useful supportive organ in the past few decades. Highlight the factors as well as areas in which this transformation could be visible.

Directive: Highlight15 marks

Introduction

Once perceived as a secondary chamber, the Rajya Sabha has transformed from a 'useless Stepney tire' to an indispensable supportive organ of India's parliamentary democracy, reflecting its growing influence and utility.

Factors Contributing to Rajya Sabha's Transformation

  • Rise of Coalition Politics: The era of coalition governments and hung parliaments has made Rajya Sabha's consent crucial for legislative business, as the ruling party often lacks an Upper House majority, necessitating greater deliberation.
  • Enhanced Deliberative Role: It has emerged as a vital revising and deliberative chamber, meticulously scrutinizing legislation. This detailed examination by experienced members improves the quality and efficacy of bills.
  • Platform for Expertise: Rajya Sabha provides a platform for distinguished individuals, experts, and diverse voices, enriching parliamentary discourse and policy formulation with specialized knowledge.

Areas Where Transformation is Visible and its Utility is Evident

  • Guardian of Federalism: Rajya Sabha actively safeguards federal principles, representing states' interests and preventing hasty centralisation. Its special powers under Articles 249 and 312 underscore this role.
  • Legislative Check: It plays a crucial role in passing constitutional amendments and non-money bills, often acting as a necessary check on the Lok Sabha's majority, ensuring broader consensus.
  • Accountability and Scrutiny: The Upper House has intensified scrutiny of government policies and administration through robust questions, debates, and effective parliamentary committees, holding the executive accountable.

Conclusion

Rajya Sabha's journey from a perceived appendage to a pivotal legislative and deliberative body highlights its indispensable role in upholding constitutional values, ensuring federal balance, and strengthening India's parliamentary democracy.

229 words · target ~250