Q16.Once a speaker, Always a speaker’! Do you think the practice should be adopted to impart objectivity to the office of the Speaker of Lok Sabha? What could be its implications for the robust functioning of parliamentary business in India.

The Speaker's office demands impartiality to uphold parliamentary dignity and rules. The 'Once a Speaker, Always a Speaker' convention, inspired by the UK model, aims for political neutrality by guaranteeing re-election without contest.

Arguments for and Challenges in India

Adopting this practice could significantly enhance objectivity by freeing the Speaker from party pressures and the need to seek re-election, fostering true independence in presiding over the House.

However, India's strong party-line politics, the Speaker's accountability to constituents, and difficulty finding candidates willing to permanently abandon party affiliations present significant hurdles.

Implications for Robust Functioning

Positive implications include ensuring fairer conduct of proceedings, better protection of minority rights, and more stable parliamentary procedures, thereby enhancing the House's overall dignity.

Potential negative implications involve detachment from political realities, reduced accountability to the electorate, and significant implementation challenges without broad political consensus.

While ideal for fostering impartiality, its adoption in India requires careful consideration of our unique political landscape and constitutional framework, necessitating broad political will and consensus.