GS 2 · 2018Indian Polity15 Marks

Q8.India and the USA are two large democracies. Examine the basic tenets on which the two political systems are based.

Directive: Examine15 marks

Introduction

India and the USA, as two of the world's largest democracies, exemplify diverse approaches to democratic governance. While both nations are committed to liberty, justice, and popular sovereignty, their political systems are rooted in distinct constitutional philosophies and operational designs.

Key Similarities in Tenets

  • Constitutionalism: Both operate under written constitutions, guaranteeing fundamental rights (India's Fundamental Rights, USA's Bill of Rights) and establishing an independent judiciary with powers of judicial review.
  • Democratic Principles: Both uphold universal adult franchise, popular sovereignty, and the rule of law, ensuring representative governance and protection of individual liberties.
  • Federalism: Both are federal states, distributing powers between national and state governments, though with varying degrees of centralisation.

Key Differences in Tenets

  • Constitutional Framework: India's Constitution is detailed, flexible, and the world's longest. The USA's is brief, rigid, and emphasizes constitutional supremacy.
  • Form of Government: India is a Parliamentary Republic (fusion of powers, executive accountable to legislature). The USA is a Presidential Republic (strict separation of powers, checks and balances).
  • Federalism & Judiciary: India is quasi-federal with a strong unitary bias and integrated judiciary. The USA has stronger federalism with a dual judiciary.
  • Citizenship & Sovereignty: India practices single citizenship and parliamentary sovereignty (within 'basic structure'). The USA allows dual citizenship and emphasizes constitutional supremacy with a rigid amendment process.

Conclusion

Despite these foundational differences, both India and the USA demonstrate the resilience and adaptability of democratic ideals. Their distinct systems reflect unique historical contexts and societal needs, yet collectively uphold the global commitment to democratic governance.

240 words · target ~250