GS 1 · 2018Indian Society10 Marks

Q11.How is the Indian concept of secularism different from the Western model of secularism? Discuss.

Directive: Discuss10 marks

Introduction

Secularism means separating religion from state. Both Western and Indian models uphold religious freedom, but their approaches differ significantly.

Western Model of Secularism

This model, exemplified by France, mandates strict separation between state and religion. The state remains neutral, non-interfering in religious affairs, focusing on individual freedom, often restricting public religious displays.

Indian Model of Secularism

Indian secularism adopts 'principled distance'. The state respects all religions equally (Sarva Dharma Sambhava) and can intervene for equality, social reform, and minority rights. It is accommodative.

Key Differences

  • Strict separation (West) vs. Principled intervention (India).
  • Individual freedom (West) vs. Individual & community rights (India).
  • Non-interference (West) vs. Reformist/protective state (India).
  • Neutral/anti-religious (West) vs. Multi-religious/accommodative (India).

Conclusion

Indian secularism, enshrined in its Preamble and Articles 25-28, is a unique, context-specific model fostering harmony and reform in a diverse society, unlike the West's rigid separation.

129 words · target ~150